Migration and transnational networks of German Mennonites from Central Asia

German Mennonites in Central Asia - Thematic Context

With the end of the Soviet Union in the 1990s, significant migration movements began in the former Eastern Bloc. The group of so-called Russian Germans in particular played a significant role in the context of immigration movements to the Federal Republic of Germany. As a result of emigration from the successor states of the Soviet Union, complex networks of relationships of migrant cultures developed between Germany and this region, which continue to play a central role in the lives of the Russian Germans today. A small group of these Russian Germans who immigrated to Germany and have received little scholarly attention to date are the Mennonites from Kyrgyzstan.

The origins of the Mennonite religious community, which can be traced back to the Anabaptist movement of the Reformation period, lie in the North German-Dutch cultural area. Central to them are believers' baptism and the complete rejection of violence, which includes, among other things, the rejection of military service. The movement was named after the reformer Menno Simons, who came from West Frisia. Expelled from the Netherlands in 1521, they migrated via East Frisia to the Vistula delta, which they reclaimed.

After increasing pressure from the Mennonites, who were now living under Prussian rule, large groups of them emigrated to Russia from 1763 at the invitation of Catherine the Great. Here they enjoyed privileges such as religious freedom and exemption from military duties. Agricultural colonies such as Khoritza and Molotschna near today's Zaporizhzhya were established, especially in today's Ukraine, which expanded to the Volga River in the following decades. The increasing Russification policy and the pressure on the Mennonites' religious principles led to several waves of emigration: While the majority of the Mennonites left their homeland for the USA and Canada, a smaller group was invited to Turkestan, which had only recently been conquered by Russia, under guarantee of exemption from military service. In 1882, this group of about 500 Mennonites - made up of families from Trakt (Volga region) and Molotschna - founded the villages of Gnadenfeld, Gnadental, Köppental and Nikolaipol (today combined to form the community of Bakaiata) in present-day Kyrgyzstan.

Due to the growing population, the village of Bergtal was founded in 1927 by landless inhabitants of villages that had already existed since the 1880s. Soon after, this settlement was renamed Red Front by Soviet authorities and kept this name until today. Under Soviet rule, the situation of the Mennonites in the Talas Valley deteriorated dramatically. Due to collectivisation, the general standard of living fell and the practice of religion was severely restricted. With the beginning of the war, the inhabitants were at the mercy of reprisals and the terror of the regime because of their German origin. Due to their peripheral location, the Kyrgyz-Mennonites were not deported; however, they were forced to work in the Trudarmija (labour army), which cost many members of the community their lives.

Only in the course of the 1950s did the situation slowly normalise for the emigrated Germans. Nevertheless, the majority of the Mennonites took advantage of the possibility, which had existed since the 1970s, to apply for emigration to the FRG. At the latest with perestroika and the collapse of the Soviet Union, most of the inhabitants left the colonies in Central Asia. They emigrated to Germany and settled mainly in East Westphalia. In Rot-Front, however, some families remained who still use the German language in everyday life. Another special feature - which underlines the connection to Germany - is the seasonal migration that takes place between Rot-Front and Germany. Former inhabitants of the village spend the summer in Kyrgyzstan, although they have actually been living in Germany for years.

Research questions and objectives

Despite their large share in the population of the Federal Republic, Russian-German communities have been little researched so far. There is little literature, especially on cultural topics such as networks and memory culture. Likewise, the amount of academic literature on the Mennonites from Kyrgyzstan is scanty, or non-existent.... The project aims to close these gaps and to bring the history of the Germans in Kyrgyzstan more into focus.

The theoretical framework of the project is formed by different approaches from cultural and social geography. The study is based on theories of religiously motivated migration. In addition, the transnational and seasonal migration that takes place between Kyrgyzstan and Germany to this day is considered. This aspect of migration has received little attention in research so far, but it can make a significant contribution to understanding migration as a circular process on the one hand, and the transnational social spaces that have emerged in this way on the other. A particular focus is on landscapes of memory in precisely this transnational context. Landscapes of memory refer to spatially organised remembering practices that, in interaction with material arrangements, constitute memories and thus part of the identity of the individuals performing them.

Based on the thematic context and the scientific approach, the following goals and research projects arise for the project:

  1. Research and presentation of the main lines of development of the German Mennonite settlements in Kyrgyzstan
  2. Analysis and presentation of the interconnections between these settlements and other Mennonite communities in parts of the former Soviet Union, in Germany and the USA
  3. Identification of transnational manifestations (identities, networks etc.)
  4. Analysis and representation of common landscapes of memory of the German-Kyrgyz Mennonite communities

These goals will be achieved through the use of different methods: Qualitative interviews with (former) residents of Red Front and the method of participant observation will primarily examine transnational social spaces and landscapes of memory as well as interconnections with other communities. With the help of an online-based WebGIS, these interconnections will be depicted. A project seminar with students from the University of Tübingen is also taking place as part of the project and data collection.

Results

Further results of the project will be summarised here at a later date. Here you will also find a link to the WebGIS and references to further publications that have been produced within the framework of the project.

Project partners

Martin Opitz Library, Herne

Mennonitische Forschungsstelle des mennonitischen Geschichtsvereins e.V., Bolanden

Museum for Russian-German Cultural History, Detmold

Project funding

Further information

Contact

Project head
Prof. Dr. Sebastian Kinder
Rümelinstr. 19-23, Raum H611
72070 Tübingen
Tel.: +49 (0) 7071 29 73938
Mail: sebastian.kinder@uni-tuebingen.de